Under guise of ‘math help,’ HS pushed girl’s gender transition — and state took her away, says her Catholic parents’ lawyer

Under the guise of “math help,” a Massachusetts high school pushed for a girl’s gender transition — and soon the state took her away, her Catholic parents’ lawyer tells Blaze News.

Indeed, the Trump administration has launched an investigation into the girl’s school district after reports that school officials “allegedly facilitated” her “gender transition” without her parents’ “knowledge or consent.”

‘Sophie should not only be returned to her parents, but there should be civil and criminal penalties for such misconduct by government agents.’

Joseph and Arlene Kutzko said their daughter Sophie has been in the custody of the Massachusetts Department of Children and Families since December 2024 — when she was 15 — after the Kutzkos refused to recognize her as a boy or call her by male names and pronouns, the Boston Herald reported, adding that the state also issued a permanent restraining order against the Kutzkos.

Vernadette Broyles, the Kutzkos’ attorney, told Blaze News that the parents were kept in the dark and told that Sophie was getting “math help” at Algonquin Regional High School in Northborough while a counselor allegedly “socially transitioned” her — so the parents were “deceived, actually.”

“They’re a beautiful family,” Broyles told Blaze News, adding that “it’s been hell on earth” for the Kutzkos as they do battle with three separate courts in their quest to regain custody of her and are stretched to the limit financially.

Meanwhile, Democrat Massachusetts Gov. Maura Healey told the Herald that the gender issue has nothing to do with why the Kutzkos’ daughter was taken from them.

“Let me be clear about the facts in that matter,” Healey said, according to the paper. “First of all, DCF did not remove the child because of a health issue or a gender-affirming care issue. DCF removed the child after there were criminal charges filed against the parents, including the father. As you know, DCF is responsible for the care and well-being of kids, and that’s what happened in this instance.”

But Broyles countered to the Herald that physical and sexual abuse charges against the parents were deemed unfounded in juvenile court, and there was no finding of guilt in criminal court following a non-guilty disposition with prosecutors: “It’s very dishonest, because there are no standing charges against them.”

Meanwhile, as the Kutzkos’ legal fees ballooned past $150,000, Broyles noted to the paper that an unidentified adult allegedly helped Sophie get a restraining order against her parents when she had been in state custody for nearly a year — and that the order still stands.

Broyles noted to Blaze News that the restraining order includes “no contact” and that “it’s my understanding that [the Department of Children and Families] supported” the order.

What’s more, an allegation of neglect against the Kutzkos still looms — and “it’s never been explained to them,” Broyles told Blaze News.

But Broyles said she has a good idea what it’s all about.

Broyles told Blaze News the “implication” is that the neglect allegation has to do with the Kutzkos’ refusal to agree to their daughter’s desire for a medical gender transition — “but Massachusetts doesn’t want to say that.”

Meanwhile, despite no finding of guilt against the parents, the Kutzkos have “not been allowed to see or talk to their daughter or observe her for 20 months,” Broyles told Blaze News.

“You’ve got to be kidding me,” their attorney added to Blaze News. “How are these people so dangerous to her? … I believe we have a state that, at its core, believes these parents are unsafe, [and] they are hiding behind a nebulous neglect. Nothing else adds up.”

Despite Sophie having been a “very faithful Catholic girl” and “so active in the church,” Broyles told Blaze News that “girls go down rabbit holes that suck them into this belief system” counter to parents’ wishes, and that’s “probably what happened to” Sophie, while those in custody of her are “championing” her gender transition. To wit: Broyles also told Blaze News that Sophie has been placed on birth control, is living in a male facility, and “now they want to give her testosterone,” which her father — a scientist — is totally against.

“She’s probably pretty manipulated by now,” Broyles told Blaze News.

RELATED: Blaze News investigates: Democrats attack parents and parental rights in Colorado

C.J. Doyle, executive director of the Catholic Action League of Massachusetts, added to Blaze News that the Massachusetts Department of Children and Families “is an unelected and unaccountable government bureaucracy with a long and disreputable history of arbitrary, autocratic, and authoritarian behavior, hostile to both parental rights and religious freedom.”

Doyle also told Blaze News that the DCF’s actions against the Kutzkos amount to “nothing less than state-sponsored kidnapping and government-inflicted child abuse. It is a direct assault, by rogue state actors, on parental authority, family integrity, and constitutionally protected religious liberty.”

Doyle also argued that “Sophie should not only be returned to her parents, but there should be civil and criminal penalties for such misconduct by government agents.”

As for the Trump administration’s involvement, the U.S. Department of Education’s Student Privacy Policy Office on Thursday launched an investigation into the Public Schools of Northborough and Southborough in Massachusetts to determine whether the school district violated the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment and the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act in relation to the Kutzkos’ case.

“Parents have a right to know what is happening with their children at school, particularly when it concerns deeply personal matters involving their health and well-being,” said Frank Miller, director of the Student Privacy Policy Office. “These egregious allegations are not an isolated problem. Families deserve answers, and SPPO will thoroughly investigate reports like this and hold any educational institution that violates federal law accountable.”

Algonquin Regional High School and the Northborough-Southborough Regional School District denied all of the Kutzkos’ allegations, calling them “baseless” and “grossly insensitive, intrusive, and dangerous toward the child,” according to the Herald.

The paper said it has requested comment from the DCF.

The Kutzkos’ next court appearance is scheduled for Oct. 29, the Herald said.

Like Blaze News? Bypass the censors, sign up for our newsletters, and get stories like this direct to your inbox. Sign up here!