By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Concealed RepublicanConcealed Republican
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • Guns
  • Politics
  • Videos
Reading: Amy Coney Barrett’s recusal leaves religious liberty twisting in the wind
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Font ResizerAa
Concealed RepublicanConcealed Republican
  • News
  • Guns
  • Politics
  • Videos
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • Guns
  • Politics
  • Videos
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Advertise
  • Advertise
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Concealed Republican > Blog > News > Amy Coney Barrett’s recusal leaves religious liberty twisting in the wind
News

Amy Coney Barrett’s recusal leaves religious liberty twisting in the wind

Jim Taft
Last updated: May 27, 2025 3:16 pm
By Jim Taft 13 Min Read
Share
Amy Coney Barrett’s recusal leaves religious liberty twisting in the wind
SHARE

The U.S. Supreme Court’s 4-4 deadlock last week left intact the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s ruling against St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School — a failure of constitutional courage and a setback for educational freedom.

The tie lets stand a decision that discriminates against faith-based institutions by denying them the same public charter school opportunities extended to secular organizations. It rests on a misguided reading of the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause and ignores the protections guaranteed by the Free Exercise clause.

Families deserve more than crumbling bureaucracies and ideological indoctrination. They need real alternatives — the kind private and parochial schools have offered for generations.

Plaintiffs, including the Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board, made a compelling case: Excluding St. Isidore solely because of its Catholic identity violates the Constitution.

In Carson v. Makin (2022), the Supreme Court ruled that states cannot deny religious organizations access to public benefits otherwise available to all. Charter schools, while publicly funded, operate independently and serve as laboratories of innovation. St. Isidore committed to meeting Oklahoma’s curriculum standards and serving any student who applied. Its disqualification stemmed from one reason alone: its religious mission.

That’s religious discrimination, plain and simple.

The Oklahoma Supreme Court misread the Establishment Clause, and the U.S. Supreme Court failed to correct the error. The clause doesn’t forbid religious organizations to participate in public programs. It forbids the state to establish an official religion — not from offering families the freedom to choose a Catholic education within a public framework.

St. Isidore wouldn’t force anyone to adhere to Catholic doctrine. It would simply give parents another option — one grounded in a Judeo-Christian worldview and committed to academic excellence. Banning that option undermines pluralism and silences voices that have historically delivered high standards and moral clarity in American education.

Meanwhile, public education in the United States teeters toward collapse. Students trail their peers globally. In some districts, basic literacy remains out of reach. Families deserve more than crumbling bureaucracies and ideological indoctrination. They need real alternatives — the kind private and parochial schools have offered for generations.

Faith-based schools routinely outperform their government-run counterparts. Instead of blocking them from public charter programs, states should welcome their success and harness their model. Innovation doesn’t threaten the system. It might save it.

Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond, despite claiming to be a Republican, sided with liberal secularists in opposing St. Isidore. His legal brief warned of “chaos” and raised alarm over hypothetical funding for “radical Islamic schools” — a tired slippery-slope argument that ignores the core issue of equal treatment under the law.

RELATED: This red-state attorney general has declared war on the First Amendment

Bill Clark/CQ-Roll Call Inc. via Getty Images

Drummond abandoned conservative principles like school choice and religious liberty. Instead, he backed those who place rigid interpretations of church-state separation above fairness. His stance helped fuel the Supreme Court’s deadlock and undercut Oklahoma families seeking diverse educational options.

The Supreme Court’s failure to resolve this question, due in part to Justice Amy Coney Barrett’s recusal, leaves a constitutional gray area: Can states bar religious organizations from public programs that remain open to everyone else?

Parents deserve the right to choose schools that reflect their values — whether religious or secular. By excluding St. Isidore, the state has effectively declared that faith-based institutions are second-class citizens. That’s not just bad policy. It’s a dangerous precedent in a nation founded on religious liberty.

The founders never intended to wall off religion from public life. They saw the Christian faith and Judeo-Christian values as cornerstones of strong, free societies. Most early American schools were church-run. Today, the pendulum has swung too far to the left. Progressive bureaucrats attack the very moral foundations that made America successful in the first place.

If we want to make America great again, we need to reclaim those values and push back against the cultural nonsense that sidelines faith.

If we want to reverse the decline of American education, we need more choices — not fewer. This fight isn’t over. Oklahoma will keep defending parental rights and religious freedom. The St. Isidore case remains unfinished business — and we intend to finish it. Faith-based schools must have the freedom to educate our children without unconstitutional restrictions.



Read the full article here

You Might Also Like

Biden judge blocks Trump’s order to dismantle the Department of Education

Bill Belichick omits Robert Kraft in new book: report

NFL charged players over $12M in fines in 2024, including 27 fines for ‘obscene gestures’

Masters viral moment: Patton Kizzire crawls in shrubbery to line up shot

Will S.C. Lawmakers Help Those Still Facing Gun Possession Charges Despite Permitless Carry Law?

Share This Article
Facebook X Email Print
Previous Article Jennifer Lopez stuns with steamy kisses during American Music Awards performance Jennifer Lopez stuns with steamy kisses during American Music Awards performance
Next Article ‘Not Normal’: Dems Say Their Party Members ‘Have Begun To Speak Like Professors’ ‘Not Normal’: Dems Say Their Party Members ‘Have Begun To Speak Like Professors’
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

- Advertisement -
Ad image

Latest News

Oregon Senate Passes Gun Control Bill with Bump Stock Ban
Oregon Senate Passes Gun Control Bill with Bump Stock Ban
Guns
Bannon Torches MSNBC for Lying About Trump’s Immigration and Justice Agenda [WATCH]
Bannon Torches MSNBC for Lying About Trump’s Immigration and Justice Agenda [WATCH]
Politics
Cheapskate Canada ‘threatens’ NORAD? Trump dangles 51st-state solution
Cheapskate Canada ‘threatens’ NORAD? Trump dangles 51st-state solution
News
Yellowstone wreck driver was at twice the legal alcohol limit, police say
Yellowstone wreck driver was at twice the legal alcohol limit, police say
News
Nationwide Sex Trafficking Bust Nets Over 30 Arrests, Rescues 70 Victims [WATCH]
Nationwide Sex Trafficking Bust Nets Over 30 Arrests, Rescues 70 Victims [WATCH]
Politics
Bono, Rogan, Rubio and Musk on USAID Funding
Bono, Rogan, Rubio and Musk on USAID Funding
Politics
© 2025 Concealed Republican. All Rights Reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Press Release
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?