The left’s new anti-Christian smear backfires — exposing its deepest fear

The left’s new favorite boogeyman — so-called “Christian nationalism” — is back in the headlines. But don’t be fooled by the narrative. The real story isn’t about Christian extremism but an obsession with tarring faithful conservative Christians.

After police arrested Vance Boelter — the man accused of targeting two Minnesota politicians and their spouses, which included murdering state Rep. Melissa Hortman (D) and her husband — the media seized on Boelter’s associations with charismatic Christianity and his background as a preacher.

If there is anything Americans should be concerned about, it’s the leftist ideology that seeks to replace God with government and silence dissent in the name of progress.

Quickly, a narrative was born: Boelter is yet another example of “Christian nationalism” and far-right extremism.

• Wired: The Minnesota shooting suspect’s background suggests deep ties to Christian nationalism
• The Forward: Understanding accused Minnesota shooter Vance Boelter’s ties to Christian nationalism
• Washington Post: Minnesota shooting suspect went from youthful evangelizer to far-right zealot
• New York Magazine: The spiritual warfare of Vance Boelter
• MSNBC: Killings in Arizona and Minnesota shine light on the crisis of Christian extremist violence

At the New York Times, evangelical columnist David French wrote about the “problem of the Christian assassin,” using Boelter as a cudgel to smear Christians — and take a shot at President Donald Trump.

“And right now — at a time when the Christian message of grace and mercy should shine the brightest — America’s Christian extremists are killing people, threatening and intimidating public servants and other public figures who oppose Trump and trying to drive their political opponents from the public square,” French claimed.

In the view of leftists and media pundits, this heinous act of violence wasn’t the result of one individual’s sin but the inevitable fruit of “Christian nationalism.” If you hear them tell the story, Boelter’s views of Christianity gave him license to act. But it’s a lie.

Guilt by faith

Let’s be honest about what’s happening here: The media, leftists, and opponents of President Trump use the label “Christian nationalism” to smear conservative Christians.

In the media, “Christian nationalism” has become an elastic term that is stretched to cover anyone who believes a biblical worldview should influence public life and anyone who wants their communities to be more Christian.

Do you oppose the LGBTQ+ agenda? Christian nationalist. Do you oppose giving children “trans-affirming” drugs? Christian nationalist. Do you believe that life begins at conception? Christian nationalist. Are you a Christian who supports President Trump? Christian nationalist. Do you believe that America was uniquely founded on Judeo-Christian principles? Christian nationalist. Jesus is Lord? Christian nationalist.

The goal of the “Christian nationalist” panic is clear: to discredit and silence Christians for refusing to go along with the leftist agenda.

By connecting isolated violent acts to “Christian nationalism,” they make all conservative Christians guilty by association. This is their narrative: Your faith is suspect, your convictions are dangerous, and your faith, if taken seriously, is a threat to democracy — or worse.

Faith, not extremism

The media and leftists who fearmonger about “Christian nationalism” are intentionally omitting basic truths.

Loving your country and wanting it to flourish is not the type of “nationalism” (i.e., fascism) they accuse conservative Christians of advocating for. Believing in biblical truth and voting in alignment with biblical values is not “extremism,” and it certainly isn’t an attempt to impose a theocracy on everyone else. Christians who speak about Christ publicly — and want their communities to reflect Christian values — aren’t calling for a state religion.

Despite their accusations, conservative Christians are not inclined toward violence.

We want moral sanity. We don’t want the progressive agenda shoved down our throats. We want to raise our families in healthy, peaceful communities. We want every American to know and experience the goodness of God and the riches of a relationship with Him.

It’s not radical, and it’s certainly not extreme.

What they really fear

The heinous acts that police accuse Vance Boelter of committing on the morning of June 14 are not Christian. They are pure evil.

No faithful Christian would disagree with that assessment. And yet, the media rushed to connect an isolated act of evil to all conservative Christians in the name of “Christian nationalism” when there is no link at all.

Not only is it dishonest, but it underscores yet another leftist double standard.

When far-left progressives commit violence, the media instructs us not to rush to judgment. When leftist ideologies produce bloodshed, we’re told to wait for the full story. But when an alleged conservative or Christian commits violence (two claims about Boelter that remain more tale than truth), the entire conservative Christian movement is put on trial and swiftly condemned.

The distinction between what the media and leftists define as “Christian nationalism” and actual conservative Christianity is important. Not just for the sake of truth — although truth is important — but for the sake of every Christian trying to follow Jesus in a world that increasingly calls evil “good” and good “evil.”

If there is anything Americans should be concerned about, it’s the leftist ideology that seeks to replace God with government and silence dissent in the name of progress. The real story here isn’t that Christianity turns people violent or results in extremism; it’s that people with an agenda who hate Christianity use any excuse to try to turn Americans against faithful believers.

The real nationalism the left fears is a nation that still believes in God and Christians who won’t be silent. Don’t let them win.