Gun Groups Push Fifth Circuit to Tie Lifetime Bans to Dangerousness, Not Felony Status
The NRA and Second Amendment Foundation have asked the full Fifth Circuit to judge lifetime gun bans on dangerousness, not felony labels alone, in a case that could reshape as-applied challenges to federal firearm prohibitions nationwide.
Snapshot
The two gun-rights groups filed an amicus brief in United States v. Cordova, a case now before the en banc Fifth Circuit after a panel rejected an as-applied Second Amendment challenge to 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1). The brief supports neither party but urges the court to adopt a historical test focused on whether a person is actually dangerous, rather than treating felony status alone as sufficient grounds for permanent disarmament.
Key points
- The case: Peter Villa Cordova pleaded guilty to firearm possession after prior convictions for drug possession and evading arrest, and preserved an as-applied challenge to the federal felon-in-possession ban.
- Proposed standard: The NRA and SAF argue colonial and founding-era laws disarmed people seen as violent threats, not nonviolent individuals who finished their sentences.
- Capital punishment argument rejected: The brief disputes using historical death-penalty eligibility for felonies as proof that lifetime disarmament was traditionally accepted, noting not all felonies were capital offenses.
- Timing: The Fifth Circuit vacated the panel ruling in September and scheduled en banc rehearing for January 2027, alongside a separate Commerce Clause case, United States v. Squire.
- Current status: Section 922(g)(1) remains fully in effect; the filing does not change Cordova's legal status or anyone else's firearm restrictions.
Quick take
This is a closely watched test of how far courts will narrow blanket felon disarmament laws under post-Bruen historical analysis. The en banc court isn't bound by the amici's framework and could adopt, modify, or reject it entirely, but the outcome will likely influence how similar as-applied challenges are handled well beyond Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi.
Read the full story: concealednation.org