Judge Dismisses DOJ Suit on Procedural Grounds, Leaves Md. Gun Buffer Zone Intact
A federal judge in Maryland has dismissed the Justice Department's challenge to Montgomery County's 100-yard gun restriction zone around parks, schools, libraries and houses of worship, leaving the county's carry limits in place for now.
Snapshot
U.S. District Judge Theodore Chuang threw out DOJ's suit against Montgomery County's buffer-zone law on Nov. 9, finding the department's complaint didn't allege the kind of police "pattern or practice" required under the statute it sued under. The ruling doesn't address whether the law itself is constitutional, and it lands alongside a separate, still-active case brought by an Orthodox synagogue over the same restrictions.
Key points
- The statute DOJ used: The department sued under 34 U.S.C. § 12601, arguing enforcement of an unconstitutional law amounts to a "pattern or practice" of rights violations by police, a reading Chuang called "a breathtakingly broad expansion of federal power."
- What's unresolved: Chuang never ruled on whether the 100-yard buffer violates the Second Amendment; he dismissed on procedural grounds and denied DOJ's request for an injunction.
- Appeal window: DOJ, which is pursuing a similar theory against Glendale, California, has until Jan. 8, 2027, to appeal.
- Parallel fight: Silver Spring Jewish Center and Rabbi J. Menashe Shapiro are separately challenging the law; a judge already blocked enforcement inside their sanctuary but upheld the school and park buffers, and they appealed to the Fourth Circuit on Nov. 6.
- Enforcement pause: County prosecutors have agreed to hold off on criminal charges while the synagogue case proceeds, but police can still issue civil citations up to $500.
Quick take
The DOJ loss turns on a procedural technicality, not a constitutional finding, so the underlying question of whether Montgomery County's buffer zones survive Second Amendment scrutiny remains open and will likely hinge on the synagogue's Fourth Circuit appeal.
Read the full story: thefirearmblog.com