Mental illness has become a political identity — and SURPRISE, it’s on the left: Study

There have been numerous studies in recent years highlighting correlations between political affiliation and mental health.

A 2021 study published in the journal SSM-Mental Health, for instance, concluded — on the basis of an analysis of depressive attitudes among conservative and liberal 12th graders from 2005 to 2018 — that “conservatives reported lower average depressive affect, self-derogation, and loneliness scores and higher self-esteem scores than all other groups.”

‘These findings have far-reaching consequences.’

A 2023 study conducted by Gallup on behalf of the Institute for Family Studies found that adolescents with “very conservative parents are 16 to 17 percentage points more likely to be in good or excellent mental health compared to their peers with very liberal parents.”

A 2025 study published in the journal PLOS One found that “even after accounting for a variety of other factors, there is a clear propensity of conservatives to provide more positive assessments of their mental health in comparison to liberals” — although the researchers ultimately attempted to credit this tendency to stigma or survey terminology.

The American left’s mental health issues show no signs of clearing up. In fact, while conservatives continue to enjoy relatively superior mental health, the sickness on the other side appears to be attracting sufferers into a political identity all its own.

In a study strongly recommending “replication and further exploration” that was recently published in the journal Political Behavior, Lauren Van De Hey of Utah State University found that “mental health identity has begun to function as a political identity for some individuals,” particularly among “younger (Gen Z) and more liberal Americans.”

RELATED: Actress Elliot Page mocked ruthlessly after trying to define ‘healthy masculinity’

Samuel Corum/Getty Images

Utilizing data from the national Cooperative Election Study administered by YouGov in 2022, the Utah researcher determined that a great many people now “categorize themselves as having had a mental illness, the vast majority of whom view mental illness identity and mental illness alienation as important to their sense of self.”

“People who have experienced mental illness feel close to others who have experienced mental illness,” wrote Van De Hey. “They are also likely to self-categorize as having or having had a mental illness, share a sense of group consciousness with others who have or had mental illness, and recognize the need to work together to change laws that are unfair to people with mental illness.”

This obviously has political implications, explained the researcher, as it correlates with “support for increased state spending on health care, education, and welfare.”

The study cited Sen. Tina Smith (D-Minn.) as an example of a political elite for whom mental health appears to have become a “politicized identity.”

Smith has on numerous occasions discussed her past experiences with depression, grouped herself with sufferers, and identified “mental health parity” as a legislative priority.

“Those more likely to categorize as having a mental illness are more likely to have a college degree; be a Democrat, liberal, and white; and have slightly lower family income,” said the study. “For both the [Mental Illness] Identity and [Mental Illness] Alienation scales, the only consequential variable is ideology: Those with higher MI identification or MI Alienation are more likely to be liberal.”

Van De Hey concluded, “These findings have far-reaching consequences for mental health advocacy and the role mental health identity will play in the political sphere — especially as Gen Z matures as a cohort.”

Dealing with a sample of 860 respondents, Van De Hey found that 26% categorized themselves as having had a mental illness in their lifetime, 22% categorized themselves as having had a physical disability, and 168 categorized themselves as having had a serious chronic physical illness.

Of the 220 respondents who said they had mental illness in their lifetime, 70% identified as “liberal” or “very liberal,” 24% identified as “moderate,” and 32% identified as “conservative” or “very conservative.”

Of the same 220 respondents, about half stated that their identity as a person with a mental health illness was “important” or “very important to them.”

Like Blaze News? Bypass the censors, sign up for our newsletters, and get stories like this direct to your inbox. Sign up here!