Hmmm: Trump Poised to Boot Massie in KY Primary?

Say, remember when analysts and advocates predicted that Donald Trump’s influence with Republican voters had already begun to fade? Media outlets like Politico and CNN licked their chops in anticipation of Trump’s humiliation in places like Indiana, where state legislators had defied Trump and refused to redistrict. Instead, Trump’s endorsed candidates booted at least five of the seven GOP incumbents who had resisted the strategy.

Politico tacitly acknowledged the obvious the day after that primary:

Trump’s loyal and energized supporters turned out to punish the incumbents, showing that his endorsement remains the gold-standard of GOP politics. That’s a bright flashing red warning to any Republicans who might be eyeing a break from Trump as he approaches the back half of his second term in office.

Is Trump about to prove a point in Kentucky, too? Trump has had a long-running feud with Republican Congressman Thomas Massie for years now, which heated up especially during the Epstein Files debacle. Massie has routinely stoked the flames of the feud, leading Trump to push for a primary challenge – even with a wafer-thin majority in the House. 

Again, many observers figured the seven-term libertarian-ish incumbent in an R+18 district could handle a primary challenge with relative ease. The last time Massie ran against an opponent in a general election was four years ago, when Massie won 65/31 over Democrat Matthew Lehman. Massie hasn’t scored below 60% in a general election ever, and won 71% of the vote in 2016.

A new poll from Quantus Insights suggests that the days of wine and roses may be coming to an end for Massie, however (via Twitchy):

NEW QUANTUS INSIGHTS POLL | May 11–12, 2026

Kentucky’s CD4 Republican primary has become one of the most closely watched House primaries in the country, and our latest survey finds Trump-backed challenger Ed Gallrein leading Rep. Thomas Massie.

📊 Kentucky CD4 GOP Primary
🔴 Ed… pic.twitter.com/eY4cvRqUnR

— Quantus Insights (@QuantusInsights) May 13, 2026

📊 Kentucky CD4 GOP Primary

🔴 Ed Gallrein: 48.3%

🔴 Thomas Massie: 43.1%

⚪️ Undecided: 7.6%

––––––––––––––––––––––––––

With leaners included, Gallrein expands his advantage.

📊 Firm + Leaners

🔴 Ed Gallrein: 52.8%

🔴 Thomas Massie: 45.1%

⚪️ Still undecided: 2.1%

––––––––––––––––––––––––––

📈 Leaner Movement

Among voters who were not completely sure yet:

🔴 Lean toward Ed Gallrein: 52.4%

🔴 Lean toward Thomas Massie: 23.4%

⚪️ Still completely undecided: 24.1%

Gallrein is winning the leaner pool by more than two-to-one, moving him above 50% when firm support and leaners are combined.  Key Takeaway[:] Massie retains a durable base of support, but Gallrein leads on the initial ballot and strengthens his position once leaners are allocated.In a nationalized Republican primary shaped by Trump’s endorsement, outside spending, and Massie’s independent brand, Gallrein enters the final stretch with the advantage.

Granted, this is only one poll, but pollsters don’t necessarily do a lot of surveys for congressional primaries. Quantus is one of the exceptions, clearly, but this is also not Quantus’ first look at the race. Six weeks ago, Quantus polled KY-04 and found Massie in the lead:

Massie’s been watching the numbers — in February he told attendees at his first campaign event that internal polls had him leading by 17 points, but the new independent poll found the race is tightening. Quantus found 46.8% of likely registered voters support Massie and 37.7% back Gallrein, with 14% undecided.

Note the difference between Quantus’ assessment today and their assessment six weeks ago:

“For an incumbent, being under 50% is not ideal,” a Quantus release said. “But a near 10-point lead in a two-man race is still a strong position, especially when the underlying numbers suggest Massie retains the advantages that usually matter most in a primary: a known name, an established base, and a political identity that fits the district better than some in Washington may assume.”

Perhaps “some in Washington” had a better sense of the situation than Quantus and the media assumed. That sounds very much like the assumptions made before Indiana’s primaries, too. When the challenger has a lead among firm voters and is also getting a 2:1 ratio among leaners, that is not just an alarm for an incumbent – it’s a full-on catastrophe in the making. Having the same poll series show this significant of a shift over the last six weeks is meaningful, even if turnout models may have more impact in primaries than polls can measure. 

Massie may have miscalculated Trump’s draw in his district, despite Trump’s 67% vote total in KY-04 in 2024. However, Massie may have another problem that has contributed to his sharp downward slide – a zipper problem, to be more specific:

Rep. Thomas Massie’s (R-KY) former girlfriend accused the congressman of offering her money to drop a wrongful termination complaint against one of his closest allies, just days before Kentucky’s Republican primary. …

Cynthia West, who dated Massie for roughly six months between late 2024 and early 2025, alleged the congressman arranged for her to work in Rep. Victoria Spartz’s (R-IN) office shortly after they began dating so she could spend more time with him in Washington, D.C.

After the couple broke up, West said she was wrongfully terminated from Spartz’s office and later offered $5,000 by Massie to drop a complaint against the Indiana Republican.

West said she was also offered a separate $60,000 settlement tied to her wrongful termination complaint against Spartz, but declined because it included a nondisclosure agreement.

West spoke with Axios’ Marc Caputo and accused Massie of attempting to intimidate her from filing an ethics complaint against Spartz. West told Caputo that made Massie’s supposed championing of Epstein victims massively hypocritical:

When she called Massie to inform him that she was filing a complaint against Spartz, she said he offered to give her $5,000 in cash.

• West said the money was half of the $10,000 he gave to her in an envelope of $100 bills when they first began dating as a surety for incidentals if West, a single mom, left her job to work for Spartz and needed the money. …
• “You’re just one person. You’re not going to make a difference. Just walk away,” West said Massie told her. …

• “I thought one person couldn’t make a difference and that victims should just walk away or was that just me?” she replied on Sept. 11.
• “It really bothered me watching him with the Epstein Files because he’s sitting there talking about transparency and victims’ rights and having women be heard and he literally tried to silence me,” she told Axios.

The primary will take place next Tuesday, six days from now. If Massie does lose to Gallrein, he’s likely to blame this late oppo research hit for the result. However, this poll makes it pretty clear that Gallrein had Massie’s number before West came forward this week. And so did Donald Trump. 

Editor’s Note: Help us continue to report the truth about corrupt politicians. 

Join HotAir VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.