Fifth Circuit Rules Second Amendment Covers Gun Sales, Not Just Possession
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that the Second Amendment's protections extend beyond keeping and bearing arms to cover the buying and selling of firearms, a decision that could reshape how federal and state restrictions on gun sales are judged in the circuit's jurisdiction.
Snapshot
In U.S. v. Deare, a three-judge panel reversed a lower court's denial of a motion to dismiss a federal indictment tied to dealing firearms without a license, sending the case back for further proceedings. The majority held that the right to acquire guns is inseparable from the right to keep and bear them.
Key points
- Core holding: The panel found that the Second Amendment's text protects commercial firearm transactions, not just possession, meaning restrictions on buying and selling guns must meet constitutional scrutiny.
- Case outcome: Jeremiah Deare's motion to dismiss was wrongly denied by the district court; the case is remanded for reconsideration rather than immediate dismissal.
- Dissent: Judge Catharina Jacoba Hendrika Dubbelday Hayne argued the amendment doesn't explicitly cover sellers and that Deare failed to properly challenge the rules at issue.
- Concurring pushback: Judge James Ho compared the dissent's logic to claiming the First Amendment excludes booksellers, calling that reasoning untenable.
- Licensing precedent limited: Judge Andrew Oldham wrote that the court's prior Peterson decision on "shall-issue" licensing shouldn't be stretched to cover firearm sales restrictions, arguing the government misapplied Bruen's footnote nine.
Quick take
This ruling signals that Fifth Circuit courts will now scrutinize federal and state laws restricting firearm commerce more closely, treating sellers' and buyers' rights as constitutionally linked. The concurring opinions' sharp rejection of expansive licensing deference suggests future challenges to sales restrictions in the circuit may have a stronger footing.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com