First Circuit Forces New Look at Gun Ban Over Old DUIs
The First Circuit has revived a New Hampshire man's Second Amendment challenge to a federal firearm ban rooted in two decades-old DUI convictions, ruling that the circuit's pre-Bruen precedent no longer controls the analysis.
Snapshot
On November 13, 2026, a unanimous First Circuit panel vacated the dismissal of Thomas Marshall's lawsuit, sending it back to the district court for a proper Bruen-style historical analysis. Marshall was denied a firearm purchase in New Hampshire because of 1997 and 2005 Massachusetts DUI convictions, which fall under the federal prohibition in 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1). The ruling doesn't restore his rights or strike the law, but it forces the government to actually defend the restriction constitutionally.
Key points
- Old precedent falls: Chief Judge David Barron wrote that the circuit's 2011 Torres-Rosario decision no longer controls, citing this year's Levasseur ruling, which applies Bruen's historical framework to § 922(g)(1) challenges.
- Purchase, not possession: The court let Marshall's challenge to his firearm-purchase denial proceed, but found he lacked standing to challenge criminal possession liability, since he didn't allege the interstate-commerce element required under the statute.
- DOJ restoration process looms: Judges told the lower court to weigh DOJ's new § 925(c) relief program, created under August 2026 regulations, which had granted relief to 22 people as of a February 2026 filing.
- Nothing decided yet: The panel didn't invalidate the federal ban or rule on whether Marshall's DUIs constitutionally justify it — that fight returns to the District of New Hampshire.
Quick take
For gun owners carrying old convictions on their record, this case is worth watching closely. It doesn't hand Marshall a win, but it forces courts across Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island and Puerto Rico to stop leaning on outdated circuit precedent and actually confront whether permanent, decades-later gun bans fit the nation's historical tradition.
Read the full story: ammoland.com