Florida AG Drops Defense of Bump-Stock Ban, Leaving Gun Owners in Limbo
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier has announced his office will no longer defend convictions under the state's 2018 bump-stock ban, calling the law unconstitutional under the Second Amendment.
Snapshot
Uthmeier issued a written legal opinion stating that bump stocks qualify as "arms" protected by the Second Amendment, whether classified as firearm components or accessories. He argues Florida has no historic tradition supporting a ban on devices that speed up trigger pulls, and that the law as written is overly broad, exposing lawful gun owners to up to five years in prison.
Key points
- No defense going forward: Uthmeier says his office will not defend any conviction obtained under the bump-stock statute, though the law itself remains on the books.
- Constitutional reasoning: Uthmeier contends the ban implicates the Second Amendment's plain text and that the state can't show a historical tradition of banning rate-of-fire components.
- One trigger pull, one shot: Uthmeier says bump stocks don't convert semi-automatic firearms into machine guns, since each shot still requires a separate trigger pull.
- Pattern of non-defense: This follows Uthmeier's earlier refusals to defend Florida's under-21 gun sale ban and its three-day waiting period, both also tied to the 2018 Parkland-era gun law package.
- Uncertain enforcement: There's no active litigation challenging the ban that prompted this move, and Bearing Arms' Cam Edwards notes some local prosecutors in Florida's more liberal areas may still attempt enforcement despite Uthmeier's opinion.
Quick take
Cam Edwards, writing for Bearing Arms, frames this as a win for gun owners and predicts few future prosecutions will follow, even though the statute hasn't been repealed or struck down by a court. For permit holders and gun owners in Florida, that leaves real uncertainty: the law remains valid on paper, and enforcement may still vary by jurisdiction until a court actually rules on the question.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com