Ohio Sheriff's Case Against Suppressor Bill Rests on Shaky Evidence
Ohio Senate Bill 214, which would remove suppressors and short-barreled firearms from the state's dangerous-ordnance classification, is awaiting Gov. Mike DeWine's signature, and Hamilton County Sheriff Charmaine McGuffey is publicly pushing back against it.
Snapshot
SB 214 would align Ohio law with federal practice, since the DOJ already declines to enforce NFA registration on these items after a court ruling undercut the tax basis for that requirement. McGuffey opposes the bill, citing concerns about black markets and gunshot-detection technology, while Rep. Jean Schmidt and Bearing Arms columnist Cam Edwards argue her objections don't hold up.
Key points
- What the bill does: SB 214 would let Ohioans legally possess suppressors and short-barreled firearms without the federal NFA tax-and-registration process already unenforced by the DOJ.
- Sheriff's objection: McGuffey warned the change could fuel a "pretty prolific black market" and said muffled gunshots would be harder for ShotSpotter systems to detect.
- Lawmaker pushback: Rep. Jean Schmidt told FOX19 that a flawed detection tool shouldn't limit someone's right to own a weapon, and noted suppressors help protect shooters' hearing.
- ShotSpotter's track record: An analysis by the Weekly and Type Investigations found ShotSpotter missed over 20% of Chicago shootings and reckless discharges from January 2023 to August 2024, including roughly 180 gun homicides.
- Bearing Arms' argument: Edwards contends McGuffey hasn't shown the bill would arm criminals, calling her case speculation rather than evidence, and says DeWine should sign it.
Quick take
For permit holders, this is a concrete compliance question: whether lawful ownership of suppressors and short-barreled firearms stays a state felony risk or gets resolved to match federal reality. The sheriff's objections focus on detection tech and hypothetical black markets rather than documented harm from legal ownership, which is the core tension Bearing Arms highlights.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com