Minimum Wage Fail

        Not long ago, new kinds of jobs appeared: app-based gig work.

        They include jobs like dog walking on Rover, Taskrabbit work, DoorDash food delivery, Uber and Lyft driving …

        Lots of people like gig work. It’s flexible. You work when you want to work.

        But “workers’ rights” activists and governing socialists don’t like that. Gig workers rarely join unions. They don’t get a minimum wage.

        “Uber and Lyft exploit their workers” is a headline at MS NOW. “We can’t ignore it.”

        The Democratic Socialists said they had a solution. Seattle’s city council imposed a $26 delivery driver minimum wage. 

        What could go wrong?

        Two years later, we know the answer: Gig workers make no more money, but prices went up.

        Apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats added a $5 fee for consumers “to help cover the costs of these … regulations.”

        Now Seattle residents complain about prices. “I ordered a $12 sandwich … $12 grew to $32!” complains one in my new video. “I just deleted the app.” 

        “(Work) has become slow because of the new law,” app drivers complain. DoorDash got 1.7 million fewer Seattle orders.

        This is what happens when politicians dictate wages.

        “Obviously, when you’re increasing cost to businesses, you’re going to increase costs to customers,” says economics professor Judge Glock. “These are unimaginably complicated markets where the company’s main job is interfacing between restaurants and delivery workers and customers. Then you have an economically illiterate city council or mayor who thinks, basically by looking at an industry through reading the news, they can appropriately regulate the exact wage.”

        Former Seattle City Council President Sara Nelson admits that the politicians made a mistake: “We created a problem and it’s our responsibility to fix it.”

        They repealed the harmful law?

        No.

        Nelson said they just needed to adjust their numbers: “If we had gotten the minimum pay standard right, we would not see the decline in the revenue.”

        Such conceit! Somehow, the political class knows exactly what every worker should be paid.

        Price controls never work.   

        Flexible pricing does.

        Competition forces businesses to constantly adjust pay and prices to attract workers and customers.

        When smug politicians think they can set a price that’s “right,” “it’s just patently absurd,” says Glock. “You’re not going to have any improved well-being for people, and you’re not going to have increased wages for those workers.”

        A similar minimum wage increase failed in New York City, after politicians guaranteed app-based drivers an hourly minimum of about $20.

        “The decrease in tips and increased competition for jobs offset all of the gains from that imposed minimum wage,” says Glock. “It’s this continual whack-a-mole tendency. The market responds, [so politicians] pass a new regulation to try to prevent that response. They think the next regulation will somehow squelch the greed out of the system, but there’s simply no way to do that.”

        Competition is the only good way to decide what people get paid.

        “A lot of politicians believe there’s a free lunch or a fixed pot of money that they can give out to the neediest people,” says Glock. “The actual effect was not to improve the well-being of workers, but to increase costs for customers and sabotage one of the most successful businesses in the city.”

        Every Tuesday at JohnStossel.com, Stossel posts a new video about the battle between government and freedom. He is the author of “Government Gone Wild: Exposing the Truth Behind the Headlines.”

Editor’s note: We now have the room to run syndicated commentary by some of our favorite and most provocative thinkers on the Right. That only happens because of the support of our readers, who ensure that we have the resources to keep providing an independent platform and independent voices in a sea of Protection Racket Media domination. 

Help us maintain that fight! Join Hot Air VIP and use promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your membership.