Guns

75-Year-Old Kills Intruder At Door

November 18, 2026

A 75-year-old Wisconsin homeowner shot and killed a man who allegedly tried to force his way into his house early Sunday morning, following an earlier attempt to enter a neighboring home.

Snapshot

Oneida County authorities say 35-year-old James Roath first entered an elderly woman's home around 1 AM on November 15 before she got him out and locked the door. Roath then allegedly went to Marshall Robinson's neighboring home, pounding on the side and front door. Robinson armed himself, opened the door, and fired after Roath grabbed his glasses and pushed toward the doorway. Roath died at the scene.

Key points

  • Two homes, one night: Roath allegedly entered one residence before being locked out, then moved on to Robinson's home and began pounding on it.
  • Armed and ready: Robinson grabbed a handgun before opening his door to confront the stranger pounding on his house.
  • Physical contact triggered the shot: Robinson fired after Roath allegedly grabbed his glasses and tried to shove his way inside.
  • Legal presumption cited: Bearing Arms notes Wisconsin law presumes deadly force is reasonable when someone is forcibly entering a dwelling and the defender believes that's occurring.
  • Investigation ongoing: The Oneida County Sheriff's Office continues to investigate the shooting.

Quick take

Bearing Arms columnist Cam Edwards argues Robinson had a strong self-defense case, noting the 75-year-old had no way to know Roath's intentions once the stranger grabbed at him and pushed toward the door. Edwards writes that Robinson, facing a much younger intruder, shouldn't have had to gamble his safety on a physical confrontation rather than defending himself at the threshold.

Read the full story: bearingarms.com