Two Shootings Show How Escalation—Not Just Threat—Shapes Self-Defense Law
Two fatal self-defense shootings a continent apart show why the law looks at how a confrontation started, not just who ended up pulling the trigger.
Snapshot
Bearing Arms columnist Cam Edwards compares a Detroit carjacking shooting with a St. Louis road-rage killing. In Detroit, an intended carjacking victim shot two suspects after one told the other to shoot him and his companion. In Missouri, prosecutors declined to charge a driver who shot and killed 59-year-old Vance Townes after Townes approached his car holding a gun, even though the driver had followed Townes into a parking lot after a road-rage exchange.
Key points
- Detroit case: Two suspects forced victims to their knees during an attempted carjacking; one victim drew his gun after hearing a command to shoot them, killing one suspect and wounding the other.
- Missouri case: St. Louis prosecutors said the "legal elements of self-defense were insurmountable" and declined to charge the Honda driver who shot Townes after Townes walked toward his car armed.
- Legal reasoning: Attorney Jay Kanzler said a driver confronted by an armed person approaching his vehicle has a clear legal right to use deadly force under Missouri law.
- Bad decisions, not disqualifying: Edwards argues the driver's choice to follow Townes into the lot was questionable, but it didn't erase his right to defend himself once Townes approached armed.
Quick take
Edwards's larger point for armed citizens is that owning a gun doesn't automatically make a shooting legal; prosecutors and juries scrutinize who escalated, who retreated, and who created the danger in the first place. The Detroit case looks like a clean, immediate-threat shooting, while the Missouri case shows that even a legally justified shooting can follow avoidable missteps, like driving toward trouble instead of away from it.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com