Thomas Hints Maryland Gun-Free Zone Law Could Face Future Challenge
The Supreme Court turned away a wide-ranging challenge to Maryland's gun-free zone law, leaving the state's sensitive-places carry restrictions in place for now, while Justice Clarence Thomas used the occasion to flag constitutional problems he sees in several of those provisions.
Snapshot
The Court declined to hear a case challenging Maryland's designated sensitive-place restrictions on carrying firearms, meaning the law stays in effect for permit holders in the state. Justice Thomas agreed with the denial but wrote separately to question whether some of the restrictions can survive Second Amendment scrutiny, per concealedcarry.com.
Key points
- Case denied: The Supreme Court declined to review Maryland's broad sensitive-places law, leaving its carry prohibitions intact.
- Thomas concurred on narrow grounds: Justice Thomas agreed the case shouldn't be heard, reasoning that its many distinct provisions raise separate historical and legal questions that don't fit a single appeal.
- Constitutional doubts raised: Thomas expressed serious concerns that several of Maryland's restrictions may not hold up under the Second Amendment.
- A roadmap for next time: Thomas signaled that a more narrowly tailored challenge to specific provisions could get a different reception from the Court.
- Nothing settled: The ruling postpones rather than resolves the larger question of how far states can go in restricting carry in designated gun-free zones.
Quick take
For Maryland permit holders, this changes nothing today — the sensitive-places restrictions remain the law. But Thomas's concurrence reads as an invitation: a future litigant who challenges a single, specific provision rather than the whole statute may have a better shot at Supreme Court review. Gun owners in other states with similar sensitive-place laws should watch for that narrower case to materialize.
Read the full story: concealedcarry.com