Home Invasion Shooting Shows How Castle Doctrine Protects Homeowners
A homeowner near Minden, Louisiana, shot and killed a man who cut through a window screen and entered the home with a knife, and the Webster Parish sheriff says criminal charges against the homeowner are unlikely.
Snapshot
Sheriff Jason Parker said the early morning incident on Oct. 18 began with a crashed vehicle and an alleged domestic attack on U.S. Highway 80, after which Billy McFarland, 44, of Marrero, made his way to a nearby residence, damaged vehicles, and ultimately entered through a cut window screen while still holding a pocket knife. The homeowner fired, killing McFarland, and the case now moves to the district attorney for a final charging decision.
Key points
- Entry with a weapon: Authorities say McFarland climbed onto an AC unit, cut a screen, and came through the window still holding the knife he used to cut it.
- Fear for multiple lives: Parker said the resident appeared to fear for his own safety and that of others inside the home when he fired.
- Sheriff's view isn't final: Parker's "unlikely" charges assessment is preliminary; investigators will send findings to the district attorney, who holds the actual charging authority.
- Statutory backdrop: Louisiana Revised Statutes § 14:20 covers justifiable homicide for reasonable fear of death or great harm, and creates a presumption of reasonable fear when someone unlawfully and forcibly enters an occupied dwelling.
- Open questions: Reporting reviewed by Concealed Nation did not identify the homeowner or other occupants, and McFarland's motive remains under investigation.
Quick take
This case tracks the pattern gun owners should recognize: an armed, unlawful entry into an occupied home, a sheriff's early read favoring the resident, and a legal process that still has to run its course through the district attorney before anything is final.
Read the full story: concealednation.org